Karka and Makara Compatibility
Also searched as: rashi milan, rasi porutham, gun milan, kundli milan, rashi compatibility, jadhagam porutham
Moon in Karka with Moon in Makara: the four sign-based kootas give 8.5 to 10.5 of 15 points. Add the nakshatras, and the full Ashtakoot score ranges from 12 to 29 of 36.
This is a traditional compatibility score, not a prediction of relationship success or a reason on its own to accept or reject a partner.
The four sign-based kootas
Varna, Vashya, Graha Maitri and Bhakoot depend only on the two Moon signs. Varna and Vashya are read from the boy's sign to the girl's, so both directions are shown.
| Koota | Max | Boy Karka, girl Makara | Boy Makara, girl Karka | How it is scored |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Varna | 1 | 1 | 0 | Karka is a water sign and Makara a earth sign. Varna follows the order water, fire, earth, air, and gives 1 point when the boy's sign is level with or ahead of the girl's. |
| Vashya | 2 | 1 to 2 | 1 to 2 | Vashya changes inside Dhanu and Makara, which split by the half of the sign the Moon is in, so a range is shown. |
| Graha Maitri | 5 | 0.5 | 0.5 | Moon rules Karka and Saturn rules Makara. Moon counts Saturn as neutral, and Saturn counts Moon as an enemy. |
| Bhakoot | 7 | 7 | 7 | Karka and Makara face each other (7 and 7 apart), which the classical rule does not count as Bhakoot dosha. |
| Sign-based total | 15 | 9.5 to 10.5 | 8.5 to 9.5 |
Full score by nakshatra
The other four kootas (Tara, Yoni, Gana and Nadi) depend on the nakshatras. These are every nakshatra combination possible with the Moon in Karka and in Makara, scored by the same engine as a full match. Open a pair for its complete table.
12 combinations, scores from 12 to 29 of 36. Nadi dosha appears in 4 of them.
| Nakshatras | Boy Karka, girl Makara | Boy Makara, girl Karka | Nadi |
|---|---|---|---|
| Punarvasu in Karka (pada 4) with Uttara Ashadha in Makara (padas 2 to 4) | 26 | 25 | Different |
| Punarvasu in Karka (pada 4) with Shravana in Makara (pada 1) | 28 | 27 | Different |
| Punarvasu in Karka (pada 4) with Shravana in Makara (padas 2 to 4) | 29 | 28 | Different |
| Punarvasu in Karka (pada 4) with Dhanishta in Makara (padas 1 to 2) | 21 | 20 | Different |
| Pushya in Karka with Uttara Ashadha in Makara (padas 2 to 4) | 27 | 26 | Different |
| Pushya in Karka with Shravana in Makara (pada 1) | 25 | 24 | Different |
| Pushya in Karka with Shravana in Makara (padas 2 to 4) | 26 | 25 | Different |
| Pushya in Karka with Dhanishta in Makara (padas 1 to 2) | 13 | 12 | Same nadi |
| Ashlesha in Karka with Uttara Ashadha in Makara (padas 2 to 4) | 14 | 13 | Same nadi |
| Ashlesha in Karka with Shravana in Makara (pada 1) | 14 | 13 | Same nadi |
| Ashlesha in Karka with Shravana in Makara (padas 2 to 4) | 15 | 14 | Same nadi |
| Ashlesha in Karka with Dhanishta in Makara (padas 1 to 2) | 27 | 26 | Different |
About this pairing
The Moon in Karka (Cancer) is traditionally gentle, protective and bound up with home and feeling. The Moon in Makara (Capricorn) is described as sober, ambitious and careful, tending to show devotion through duty and steady effort rather than words. The two signs lie directly opposite each other, water against earth, and both are movable (chara), so each is willing to begin and to work. Karka seeks emotional warmth, Makara seeks order and achievement. Because they are opposites, they often notice exactly what the other lacks, which can attract as much as it frustrates.
The Moon rules Karka and Saturn rules Makara. The Moon regards Saturn as neutral, while Saturn counts the Moon as an enemy, so this pairing benefits from patience and openness. Makara can say aloud the appreciation it feels, and Karka can remember that reserve is not indifference. A shared project, like building a home, managing savings or caring for relatives, gives them a common task where both strengths count. Keep a regular time to talk about feelings, kept short and kind. Quiet, dependable gestures will speak loudly to both.
A full match needs both birth charts
Moon signs and nakshatras give the score on this page. A real match also needs the exact nakshatra pada from each birth chart and each person's own Manglik standing. The free kundli matching tool computes all of it from both birth details.
Other pairs with Karka
Other pairs with Makara
Questions
What is the guna score for Karka and Makara?
The four sign-based kootas give 8.5 to 10.5 of 15. The full Ashtakoot score also depends on the two nakshatras and ranges from 12 to 29 of 36 across every combination possible in these signs. This is a traditional compatibility score, not a prediction of relationship success or a reason on its own to accept or reject a partner.
Is there Bhakoot dosha between Karka and Makara?
Karka and Makara face each other (7 and 7 apart), which the classical rule does not count as Bhakoot dosha. The rule applied here: Bhakoot dosha arises when the Moon signs sit 2 and 12, 5 and 9, or 6 and 8 apart. It is cancelled, and the 7 points are kept, when both signs share a lord or the two lords are mutual friends.
Can Karka and Makara have Nadi dosha?
Nadi depends on the nakshatras, not the signs. 4 of the 12 nakshatra combinations for these signs share a nadi. Nadi: a traditional matching factor. It does not assess genetics, fertility or health.
Is a Moon sign match enough to decide?
No. A sign gives only part of the picture. A full match uses both birth charts: the exact nakshatras, and each person's own Manglik standing. The free kundli matching tool computes all of it.
Take this to your own chart
Our Moon signs are Karka and Makara. What does that mean for our match?
Ask Purohit about this Check our full matchCreate your free kundli Chat with Purohit on WhatsApp